james buchanan
James Buchanan was not an accident. He was the establishment’s gold standard.
By the time he took office in 1857, Buchanan had spent decades marinating in Washington. Congressman. Senator. Secretary of State. Diplomat to Russia. Diplomat to Great Britain. If longevity were leadership, he’d have been unstoppable. He wasn’t a populist gamble or a backroom surprise. He was wanted. Trusted. Supposed to be steady.
Then he walked into a country already cracking down the middle.
Slavery wasn’t a debate anymore — it was a countdown. Bleeding Kansas was bleeding. The Republican Party was rising. The Supreme Court was about to drop Dred Scott like a constitutional grenade. And Buchanan, armed with process and patience, believed the system would hold if everyone just followed the rules.
History had other plans.
Buchanan didn’t start the Civil War. But as states began sliding toward secession, his legalistic restraint and refusal to confront the crisis head-on made him the last president of a Union that was already slipping away. He had the résumé. He had the reputation. What he didn’t have was a moment that rewarded caution.
In the Civil War Era, Buchanan isn’t remembered for what he built.
He’s remembered for what unraveled on his watch.
Franklin pierce
Franklin Pierce was a likable, loyal Democrat whose presidency accelerated America’s slide toward the Civil War. Shaped by personal tragedy and driven by an obsessive commitment to compromise and party unity, Pierce enforced divisive laws, enabled sectional violence, and mistook calm for stability. His presidency shows how prioritizing harmony over moral clarity can quietly make everything worse.
millard fillmore
Millard Fillmore was a self-made Whig, frontier-born reformer, and one of the most overlooked presidents in American history. This episode of The Buck Starts Here explores Fillmore’s early life, rise through law and Congress, and his unwavering belief in institutional government, compromise, and constitutional order — setting the stage for a presidency defined by impossible choices before the Civil War.
zachary taylor
If you’ve ever wondered what would happen if you force-promoted your most chaotic coworker into a CEO position, congratulations — you already understand the Zachary Taylor presidency.
Zachary Taylor was a lifelong soldier who treated politics like a mild inconvenience and bathing like an optional activity. He spent forty years fighting in muddy fields, eating whatever wasn’t moving, and accidentally collecting military victories he didn’t entirely plan — and America responded by handing him the keys to the country.
Did he have political experience? Absolutely not.
Did he have opinions about national policy? Also no.
Did he understand what the Whig Party actually believed? Hard no.
But did he show up, ignore instructions, and nearly blow up the entire slavery debate by brute-forcing anti-secession vibes into Congress? Oh, yes. Taylor was the chaotic neutral president we didn’t deserve and definitely weren’t prepared for — a man whose stubbornness briefly held the Union together before his sudden death yeeted the country back into the slow-motion disaster that would become the Civil War.
He was unpredictable. He was messy.
He was… somehow effective?
Zachary Taylor: proof that sometimes the wrong guy at the wrong time still manages to kick the can down the road just long enough for history to say, “Well… points for effort.”
james k polk
James K. Polk was the overachiever nobody invited to the party — a sickly math nerd who somehow failed his way into the presidency. He started as Tennessee’s biggest political flop, worshiped Andrew Jackson like a hype man on retainer, and still managed to expand the country like he was playing Manifest Destiny: The Home Game.
Ambitious, exhausting, and tragically competent, Polk turned being forgettable into a superpower. By the time he left office, America was bigger, angrier, and way more complicated — just like Polk probably wanted it.
John Tyler (jr)
John Tyler was the original “how did this guy end up in charge?” president. He slid into the White House not on a wave of popular support but because fate (and pneumonia) cleared the path. A states’ rights purist with a serious gold fixation and an instinctive distrust of banks, Tyler was basically the Whig Party’s emotional support problem. He was technically their guy, but only in the way a cat technically lives in your house, there on paper, utterly uncooperative in practice.
Once in power, Tyler quickly made it clear he was not about to be anyone’s party puppet. He vetoed Whig bills, torched alliances, and left a trail of political wig-flipping chaos in his wake. By the end of his accidental presidency, the Whigs had booted him from the party, Congress was over him, and America was left with a man who’d redefined “presidential drama” before reality TV was even a thing.
william henry harrison
Martin Van Buren wasn’t just some tavern kid from Kinderhook — he was the kid who figured out that serving beer to bickering politicians was the fastest crash course in power you could get. Fast forward a few decades and he’s sitting in the White House, running the country like it’s his own personal chessboard.
Nicknamed “The Little Magician” (because “Slicker Than You” was apparently taken), Van Buren mastered the backroom deal, invented the political machine, and somehow convinced Jackson he was just a loyal little sidekick. Joke’s on Old Hickory: the “puppet” was learning all the tricks of the trade, and he was damn good at it.
By the time he grabbed the presidency in 1837, Van Buren was done hiding in the wings. He had his own agenda, his own style, and the confidence to ditch the marionette strings. Problem is, his timing was trash — nothing like kicking off your presidency with a full-blown economic panic and a nation ready to riot.
So was he Jackson’s puppet? Absolutely. But then he pulled a Van Buren special: flipped the script, claimed the stage, and showed the country that the quiet Dutch kid wasn’t just a side act — he was the main event.
MARTIN VAN BUREN
Martin Van Buren wasn’t just some tavern kid from Kinderhook — he was the kid who figured out that serving beer to bickering politicians was the fastest crash course in power you could get. Fast forward a few decades and he’s sitting in the White House, running the country like it’s his own personal chessboard.
Nicknamed “The Little Magician” (because “Slicker Than You” was apparently taken), Van Buren mastered the backroom deal, invented the political machine, and somehow convinced Jackson he was just a loyal little sidekick. Joke’s on Old Hickory: the “puppet” was learning all the tricks of the trade, and he was damn good at it.
By the time he grabbed the presidency in 1837, Van Buren was done hiding in the wings. He had his own agenda, his own style, and the confidence to ditch the marionette strings. Problem is, his timing was trash — nothing like kicking off your presidency with a full-blown economic panic and a nation ready to riot.
So was he Jackson’s puppet? Absolutely. But then he pulled a Van Buren special: flipped the script, claimed the stage, and showed the country that the quiet Dutch kid wasn’t just a side act — he was the main event.
andrew jackson
From bootless brawler to unchecked power machine, Andrew Jackson is the ultimate “maybe don’t root for him too hard” story. He clawed his way out of a brutal childhood—dead parents, dead brothers, and a whole lot of Revolutionary War trauma—and somehow landed in the halls of power. By all accounts, he should’ve been a historical footnote. Instead, he became a war hero, a courtroom bruiser, and a political icon with serious main character energy. America loves a self-made man... until that man starts making laws.
And that’s where things get messy. Because once Jackson hit the White House, he brought that same brawler energy—just with more vetoes and way worse consequences. He crushed the national bank, ignored the Supreme Court, and steamrolled Indigenous nations like they were inconvenient speed bumps on his path to greatness. Jackson’s rise is fascinating, infuriating, and full of red flags we absolutely should have seen coming.
the bill of rights
From teen diplomat to exhausted president to the “Madman from Massachusetts” in Congress, John Quincy Adams made his entire life a protest against slavery and corruption. He believed public service was a duty—not a grift—and proved it by outworking, outthinking, and outlasting everyone around him. He wasn’t here to charm you. He was here to do the damn work.
Now it's your turn. Stand up. Speak out. Do the work that matters. Tune in now!
buck wild
The Buck Wild Playlist is the rowdy, no-filter bonus corner of The Buck Starts Here where hosts Kyle and Eric ditch the measured analysis for pure, unhinged chaos.
This is presidential history turned up to eleven: savage roasts, brutal scoring systems, wild tangents, and zero-holds-barred takes on America's most forgettable, frustrating, and flat-out bonkers commanders-in-chief. From epic policy fails and personal disasters to the biggest historical cop-outs (looking at you, "states' rights"), Buck Wild episodes crank the humor, crank the side-eye, and deliver the kind of raw, laugh-out-loud commentary that makes even the dullest antebellum drama feel like a roast battle.
Think of it as the after-hours edition—where the economist's spreadsheets get thrown out, the history nerd goes feral, and every president gets judged without mercy or myth-making. Perfect for fans who love the main feed's sharp insights but crave the extra layer of irreverent, high-energy madness.
Part of the The Buck Starts Here family from China Shop Productions, Buck Wild drops sporadically as bonus mayhem. Hit play if you're ready for presidential history served straight-up savage, hilarious, and buck wild.
john quincy adams
From teen diplomat to exhausted president to the “Madman from Massachusetts” in Congress, John Quincy Adams made his entire life a protest against slavery and corruption. He believed public service was a duty—not a grift—and proved it by outworking, outthinking, and outlasting everyone around him. He wasn’t here to charm you. He was here to do the damn work.
Now it's your turn. Stand up. Speak out. Do the work that matters. Tune in now!
James Monroe
James Monroe, America’s fifth president, was a Revolutionary War veteran, key diplomat, and the mind behind the Monroe Doctrine. As the last Founding Father to hold office, Monroe’s legacy includes expanding U.S. influence, navigating the complexities of slavery, and leading during the so-called Era of Good Feelings—which wasn’t as peaceful as it sounds. His presidency shaped the future of American politics, foreign policy, and the nation’s struggle with its own ideals. Dive into Monroe’s fascinating life and impact with The Buck Starts Here podcast.
James Madison
James Madison: The OG Big Brain of American Democracy
James Madison—brilliant thinker, reluctant wartime leader, and the guy who had to flee when the British set the White House on fire. His presidency was a whirlwind of war, economic chaos, and some serious "well, that escalated quickly" moments. From masterminding the Constitution to barely surviving the War of 1812, Madison’s legacy is a mix of genius, struggle, and one badass First Lady who quite literally saved history. Was he a visionary or just in way over his head? Press play and find out.
thomas jefferson
Thomas Jefferson—freedom fighter or hypocrite in chief?
Eric and Kyle dig into the life of the man who wrote about liberty… but also owned slaves. From the Louisiana Purchase to his complicated relationship with Sally Hemings, Jefferson’s story is full of contradictions that’ll make your head spin. You won’t want to miss this one.
John adams
Meet John Adams—America’s second president, a founding father who was never one to keep quiet. Born in Braintree, Massachusetts, he didn’t inherit power but fought his way to the top with intellect, determination, and a knack for making enemies.
After losing the election to Jefferson, Adams set a vital precedent by stepping aside peacefully, showing that democracy was bigger than any one leader. Adams didn’t just leave behind a legacy; he left an indelible mark on American history.
George Washington
In these inaugural episodes, we’re taking a deep (and quirky) dive into George Washington—the “Father of His Country” and America’s first president, our reluctant leader.